Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Ali Nachia Briyani Dum: Real Dum Briyani

With Damien


I remember some years back, MM Lee once mentioned that Singapore may merge with Malaysia in the future. This created such an uproar among the Malaysians, who simply don't see any reason why they would want Singapore back with Malaysia. Culturally, Singapore and Malaysia are very close and it used to be that many families have cousins and uncles across the causeway. However and time went by, the two cultures are slowly diverging.

If you think about it, Singapore and Malaysia may not be so culturally different as say East and West Germany. We speak almost the same language and share lots of common hawker foods. It's only the proportion of the mix of Malay, Chinese and Indians which are different. And when we are overseas, Malaysians and Singaporeans tend to congregate and regard each other as the same gang. So it might not be so difficult to imagine that one day in the distant future, the socio-political-economic climate might force the two countries to consider merger again.

Anyway, the Malaysia-Singapore preamble is to introduce this particular stall which is situated in the Malaysian part of Singapore. Yes, there is a thin strip of Malaysian land which bisects our island from the causeway up north right down the middle to end in the South at Tanjong Pagar. It's none other than the Tanjong Pagar Railway Station. The last bastion of Malaysia in Singapore. Yet even though it is Malaysian land, we still have to pay Singapore prices for the food and the stalls are still subjected to the NEA's cleanliness ratings. Aside from that, the Railway Station still retains that Malaysian charm of yesteryear guaranteed to bring back some feelings of nostalgia of our colonial past.



Now moving on to the topic of Dum Briyani.

There's Nasi Briyani and then there's Dum Briyani. And nowadays, stallowners are increasingly calling their Briyani "Dum" to differentiate it from "lesser" Briyanis. From what I understand, this should not be the case at all. All Briyani should be "Dum" Briyani. The lesser "Briyani" is in fact pilaf, which is essentially Nasi Minyak (Buttered/Oil Rice). Whereas in a real Dum Briyani, the rice and mutton curry is partially cooked first then combined and baked together. (pic above). This way all the aroma of the curry gets infused into the rice. Mmmmmm....

This stall is run by ex-butcher turned ex-soccer coach, Cik Ali who happens to be the father of soccer star Rafi Ali. This Pak Cik is passionate about wanting to make a proper Dum Briyani and as you can see from the picture above, this is the real deal. And furthermore, being an ex-butcher, Cik Ali also knows how to handle his meats so he only picks the best parts of the goat to make his curry.



The Briyani Rice here is light and fluffy and not over powering so you can eat lots of it and not feel too jerlak. But the real gem is the super tender and aromatic mutton which has been slow cooking in the rice. The mutton has been seasoned just right such that it does not have that strong mutton smell that puts most muttonophobics off, and it has just the right amount of fats so that the meat is not dry after cooking for so long. At $5 per plate, it is still worth it as the piece of mutton is very generous and comes with the bone. The only little drawback for me was the dhalchat which could do with a bit more ooomph and it really should be eaten when it is still piping hot during lunch time because by 2pm the rice has lost some of its ooomph. 4.25/5

Conclusion

Yummy Dum Briyani surrounded by nostalgia. Little wonder that it is recommended by foodiephiles like Yuen (Prive and Brown Sugar) and Damien (Mien).


Ali Nachia Briyani Dam
The Railway Station
Tanjong Pagar
93892615
10am to 3pm
Closed on Sundays

52 comments:

Damien said...

This is the place i go to satiate my weekly briyani fix.

Had Hamid's for lunch a month ago and the standard has dropped considerably and portions of his meats have shrunk.

Anybody tried Hamid's recently? Or was it just my unlucky day.

khim said...

oh...

tis is e briyani place tat 1 malay taxi uncle swore by!!

i told him abt hamid's n he claimed no place can beat tis store at e railway station!!

gosh, it really looks yummy!!! =)

Anonymous said...

My dad-in-law ate this since his solo days. He will travel from Keppel (still a resident there, by his old little motorbike just for the curry. Now, he's 89, still going strong and whenever we're on the way to see him, we will not forget to swing by to get this curry & briyani for him. Now, dad & mum-in-law stays with us at PaRis, we're still their loyal customer.

Cheers,

sumosumo said...

whoaa....
this bryani looks like got standard man..

must go try.... near CBD - can go try one of these days..

pchong said...

Dr...the differentiation between Dum and non Dum Briyani is the cooking method.

I believe Dum means "steam" in Hindi? Hyderabadi? Hyderabad is where the origins of Dum Briyani is supposedly at its best.

Typically, the Dum method means that it is cooked in a small sealed pot - the rice, spices, meat is sealed in the pot by a pastry which looks like a roti prata (or the pastry soup found in Country Manna). The sealed pot is then steamed for up to 4 hours...in that way, all the flavour is kept within the pot.

The best in Singapore I have found so far is in Gayatri, just next to Lau Pa Sat. They have both Briyani and Dum Briyani. The Dum Briyani here is closest to those I have sampled in New Delhi, Mumbai, and Karachi. Haven't been to Hyderabad yet, so don't know if the claims to best are true.

In Sydney, Zafran, right by the Darling Harbour serves an equally mean Dum Briyani.

pchong

ieat said...

According to Cik Ali, his briyani is cooked in a sealed pot and he uses a special cooking technique that cannot be openly revealed in a public platform like a blog. ;)

BTW aren't there any comments about the Malaysia Singapore relationship? I was looking forward to hearing some heated discussion on whether Malaysians and Singaporeans are really so much different

smart said...

Malaysian n Singaporean are kawan. It is the politician that are pouring hot n cold water.

Damien said...

Spot on - half of Singaporeans have family in Malaysia and half of Malaysians have family in Singapore - so how different can we be :)

TAG said...

Quote fm Damien,

"Had Hamid's for lunch a month ago and the standard has dropped considerably and portions of his meats have shrunk.

Anybody tried Hamid's recently? Or was it just my unlucky day."

Have to agree with Damien on Hamid's, I even came back again after 3 weeks to give them a 2nd chance with the same thinking as Damien and was disappointed yet again, probably the chicken is still alright as they can't really shrink the size of chicken drumstick. The size of the mutton has really shrunk to the level one feels like being conned, I rather pay extra to get a decent portion than to pay the same price and get sub-standard portions. Thats not the way to go and I would not go back unless I happen to pass by there, dun make the extra mile for Hamid's , trust me its not worth it anymore.

TAG

sumosumo said...

I hve more relatives from Malaysia than in Singapore, even though i am singaporean.

you should hear what my malaysian relatives hv to say about their politicians.. how they use $$ to pay people to vote for them during elections etc etc.

its the politicians who always use the spore/malayisia rivalry as a means to ddrive up so called nationalistic sentiment to win votes.

Holy Drummer said...

Wah this briyani looks 'dum' good man, must give it a try soon =)

Hey if time permits, perhaps we could hop across the causeway and feature some JB seafood ya ~ can't wait for the next getaway! Have to clear the 'dum' exams first...

liverpool1965 said...

we go for the briyani after your exams HD?
:)

Damien said...

Hi Lvp and HD, how bout' this briyani for lunch next week after Wednesday? Let me know k.

Popped by your place earlier but you were not around.

liverpool1965 said...

sure!

smart said...

Damien, Next Thurs can?

Holy Drummer said...

Sounds great! So is it wed or thurs? Both days also can =)

fatme said...

Dum Biryani the rice and mutton curry are partially cooked first. Then lay, layer by layer rice.. on top mutton spices,herbs,milk,follow by another layer order and another.Then sealed air thight and baked by having fire bottom and charcoal fire on top.Till it's fully cooked.

Mr. Anonymous said...

This one better than the Tekka market one?

fatme said...

There's one very good Dum Briyani at The juction of Perak Rd and Dunlop St.You don't get one large chunk of mutton but get some small chunk pieces of mutton in your briyani rice.

ieat said...

If you read my blog on Allaudin (Tekka) you know I was underwhelmed by it. The Dhalchat is very good though but the rest was as good. This stall the mutton is very good, but dhalchat not as good.

Anyone can second the Gayatri one beside Lau Pa Sat? What's the address?

liverpool1965 said...

Its just opposite the row of satay stalls... :)

Damien said...

Next Thursday will be good for me.

So Uncle Smart, HD confirmed?

Les, LVP, wanna join us?

Exact address of Gayatri is at the corner of Ogilvy Centre next to Guardian Pharmacy.

They have another branch at 122 Race Course Road.

Haven't tried their Dum Briyani but their curry fish good is good.

Camemberu said...

Oh my, this is THE briyani I've been wanting to try! Looks so delicious!

Haha yes, we're all kawan. I'm a Malaysian in Singapore (with relatives on both sides), so I find this political rivalry very funny.

Damien said...

"Haven't tried their Dum Briyani but their curry fish good is good"

Should be curry fish head :)

liverpool1965 said...

oooo had this for lunch with the kakis...gooddd!!!!!!!!

fatme said...

Had it for lunch,this is not cooked in a dam briyani way . Though must admit it's very good.. delicious one of better I had in long time.Thank You!

ieat said...

He cooks the rice with the mutton in the aluminium pot then scoops the rice out to put in the warmer so that the rice is not overdone.

What do you mean by "dam briyani way"?

fatme said...

Dum briyani done layer by layer,the mutton with gravy must be infuse with the rice,thus you will have some of the gravy always attach to the rice and the mutton would taste like it was baked.But has I have said this is a very good briyani find, no doubt about it and justify your rating

ieat said...

So, any Dum Briyani to recommend?

fatme said...

Can't whole heartily recomMend but this place at The juction of Perak Rd and Dunlop St is as close as Dum briyani can get in Singapore.You don't get one large chunk of mutton but get some small chunk pieces of mutton in your briyani rice.If go late the rice might get very oily.
And the dhalchat and achar are big disapointment.

Anonymous said...

I had lunch dum briyani at Perak Rd.Now i can see the difference what you mean by dum briyani the like rice and mutton taste like baked and some rice has attach gravy sauce.They don't sever the curry gravy or top it so tents to be abit dry.And the dhalchat and achar dead on..lousy.$6.00

Sham said...

I know this is a bit far to go, but if you're ever in JB, you should try this place called The Village, Briyani Cafe. It serves both North Indian and South Indian cuisine with Naans, Tandoor items and Briyani. Their specialty however is the briyani. There are 4 different types of briyani i.e Fish, Prawn, Tandoori Chicken and Mutton. Their mutton briyani preparation keeps changing weekly as each different village in India has their own way of preparing briyani. We ordered the prawn, mutton and the chicken one.Personally i like the prawn and chicken one. I found the mutton one a bit meaty but I've never really been a meat lover. The rice preparation for all were different, so you know you're not getting some standard rice with different meat preparations. The rice was spiced just right and each grain was oooh so delicious. My only grouse was that it was a tad bit oily, but hey briyani isn't exactly healthy food is it? The tandoori chicken was really soft which surprised me coz I've usually found them to be dry.
All in all, worth the trip to JB.
The address is :
15, Jalan Susur 1/1, Jalan Tun Abdul Razak. Tel: 07-222 0360
Its the row of shop houses next to the now closed Best World shopping centre. Oh, they're closed on Sundays though.

ieat said...

Tempting, very tempting!

I guess one day ieatishootipost has got to go to JB, Batam and some say
Bintan!

Anonymous said...

Perak Road biryani is Bismillah Biryani. Thanks to Fatme I went over and was bowled over. It is tremendous. Chef owns the restaurant. Knows his stuff. He is Pakistani. I tried his chicken, mutton and fish biryani and all three were superb. Yes, Fatme is right, this is the next best thing to the top notch 'dum' biryani. Thanks.

Damien said...

This is still the place for my briyani fix.

Hamid's portion seem to have shrunk the last time i had it a month ago.

And i waited for 40 minutes as the earlier batch was sold out :(

Mughals Hyderabadi Biryani at Race Course Road is another place I frequent.

Small pieces of mutton infused in basmati. Served with hard boiled eggs and beetroot.

The onion perokas are addictive too.

taukwa said...

went to the railway station to look for this stall. Silly me, didn't open my eyes big enough. I landed at another stall. I didn't know that there are 2 'food courts' at the station.

Anyway, the briyani rice I had from the 'wrong' stall was very plain in taste. My only consolation was that the chicken was tender. Or is it me trying to console myself.

Anyway, I only saw the other 'food court' after my meal and found the right Ali Nachia stall. Too bad, too full to have another go liao.

cactuskit said...

Hahahhaha. I think someone up there telling you that you fated to wait for me to eat there with you. ; )

liverpool1965 said...

I was about to say that too! :)....this kind of thing, you need a partner in crime! :)....

taukwa said...

Though I'll be glad to have your company, i'm afraid that it will be a long wait to go with you leh, Cactus.

You haven't jio me for HKM yet, though you say you will. And I believe some other food are waiting too.

JENCOOKS said...

Wah, just miss <1day and the thread grew so long.

Eh, Malaysia and Singapore very kawan leh. My mum is Sporean, married to Msian and I terbalik that, me Msian and married Sporean...hehehe....problem when we root for soccer last time Msia/Spore, it was certainly fun...

Dum is nicer than brani as the rice is smothered within.

You all so nice can jio anytime u like...

HB, you are Sec 4 student? You salute to you for your interest in this blog, bet u are the only one..

taukwa said...

ya, I agree totally. Just miss a bit only and you are lost liao. Must be on our toes to be current. Keeping up here needs more time and effort than when I was studying. Not that I put in much effort then though.

JENCOOKS said...

Taukwa,
Looks like we got to sit here 24/7....You were taukwa then now u tauhu?

Actually I got some work to do, need to burn midnite oil but what am I doing here????

cactuskit said...

its really not easy to make appointments these days. So many considerations. Work lah, family lah, other commitments lah. SO little time, so few meals so much to eat... We'll try to arrange.

taukwa said...

jencooks,

last time tauhu (softer and smoother),
now taukwa (a bit harder and won't exactly slide down the throat),
on my way to taupok (need I say more)

yup, it's past my bedtime but what I am also doing here??

taukwa said...

yup Cactus, I understand. But still my intense curiosity got the better of me and I went there for lunch yesterday. A serving of the briyani (fish, mutton or chicken) cost $5.50 now.

I was a little disappointed that the rice was not flavourful enough. But the texture of the rice (i think it was basmati) was just right. I like briyani rice to be in individual grains and not soft.

I had both the chicken and the mutton. The chicken leg was alright but I must say that the mutton was good. Done till tender and nice.

cactuskit said...

Fren, you must come with me to the street 21 AMK briyani. Not dum but superb...

taukwa said...

sure cactus, will wait for you to tjio me.

JENCOOKS said...

Taukwa,
You have become born again - Taugeh.

cactuskit said...

jencooks, you must meet our Ieat Resident Adonis. He is really some male specimen.

Also very very chatty. Caught be pleasantly by surprise.

taukwa said...

uncle, you like that talk hah, later got serious cases of 'pui chao nua' when they see the "Adonis"

JENCOOKS said...

Taukwa,
If u are not the Adonis makeover, I just call u TAUPOK lor....that was really funny, Cactus.

Borneo Gecko said...

Went to KTM on May Day with family and we fell into the food court like Taukwa (talking about history repeating itself Shheesshh!!!)

But the mutton soup (can't remember the name) inside the building's food court is power, full of flavour and oommph! For $3.50, we slurp it all up.

My wife being the soup snob (true blue Cantonese) commented very little trace of MSG and its those once a blue moon where she will drink up the soup

Will try again to see the briyani portion is really that pathetic.

Post a Comment