Sunday, March 22, 2009

Cugini Italian Restaurant: Lunch for Charity

Following the excitement over my last post on Cugini Italian restaurant, we wasted no time in organizing a menu tasting to see what else our two Italian guys can whip up in the kitchen. This time round, I am going to let our kakis do the review. So below is Sumosumo's review of the dishes.

The Cugini Menu Tasting Review - by Sumosumo

Starter: Carpaccio di pesce alla Sarda con Polvere di Bottarga + Gambero rosso Italiano con riduzione al campari (Sardinian style hand cured fish carpaccio dusted with mullet roe + Deep fried Italian red prawn with almond and bitter Campari sauce)

Generally forgettable i think, as most people didnt find it too exciting. The shrimp was a little dry after the frying, and the mullet roe failed to lift the dish. The cured fish was pretty ordinary.3.75/5

(Note from ieat: We started 40 mins late that day, so the prawns had lying in the warmer for a long time. I am sure they would have been much better fresh)



Soup: Zuppetta di pesce alla Siracusana (Sicilian style seafood soup)

Robust, hearty and rustic. The seafood bisque had a good strong crustacean, prawn taste without being too heavy as the tanginess of the tomatoes lent an appetising twist to the soup. One can imagine this being an everyday soup at home, as it had a very home cooked taste to it. For the asian palate, it was leaning on the salty side, but Gerardo said the olives and capers gave the soup its saltishness, and no salt was added - according to him, this is the way it's consumed in Sicily. Much effort was put into it, as its made from 20 different ingredients. 4.25/5.


Pasta: Spaghetti alla Sarda con aglio, olio, peperoncino, bottarga e gamberetti (Sardinia spaghetti with garlic, olive oil, chilly, mullet roe and mediterranean prawns)

Consistently good, the pasta was dense, perfectly al dente, and absorbed the simple flavors of the garlic and chili. Every ingredient was mixed in the right proportions and hence complemented each other perfectly. The pasta was so good in itself with just that nice bite and slight chewiness in its texture, so good that the prawns became almost like an afterthought. Damien, the resident carbo man who loves his noodles and pastas, found it superb. 4.5/5


Ravioli di agnello alla Siciliana con crema di carciofi e burro
(Freshly made Sicilian style lamb ravioli with artichoke cream and butter)

I found this dish excellently executed, and I am not a big fan of ravioli. The ravioli was filled with tender shredded lamb and the pasta had a rich flavor from the egg yolk which was used to make the ravioli skin. Because the ravioli is very filling on its own, having it as a sharing dish is recommended, as there are 5 raviolis served as a main dish, and one cannot eat more than 2 without feeling "jer lak". 4.25/5.

MIlanese di vitella su mostarda di Cremona
(Milanese style veal cutlet served with home made Creomna mustard sauce)

Most people did not comment on this dish, but i thought it was a very competent veal dish. The meat was tender and flavorful. Perhaps, the sauce could have been poured on separately as i would have liked the crust to retain its crispiness. 4/5.


Carre d'agnello arrostito al pepe verde con pure' di patate all'olio
(roasted lamb chops with green pepper, served with mashed potato)

I think everyone liked this dish, except for fashionfoodie's table who got theirs undercooked. The lamb had a salty marinade crust to it which brought out the flavor of the lamb well. I would have preferred a slightly sweeter type of sauce to accompany the lamb. 4.25/5

Guancette di manzo Wagyu brasate con salsa di carciofi e cacao amaro
(Braised wagyu beef cheek with artichoke sauce and bitter cocoa)

The beef in itself was as succulent as when i first tried it, to the point of melt in your mouth. (In my mind, butter made of meat). Some of the ieaters similarly found the texture to be superb, but others thought that, given wagyu with extra fat is naturally more tender, a little less braising time would have given it a texture with more bite. However, it was generally agreed that the accompany sauce was too bland and the beef itself could have done with a more intense seasoning. Tenderness: 4.9 (if you like your meat tender) 4/5 for the artichoke and cocoa sauce. Generally the feeling was that either a stronger sauce or stronger seasoning would have given the dish a bigger lift. Overall 4.25/5.

Dessert: (Tiramisu and Panna Cotta)
The tiramisu had not enough mascarpone cheese, too much cake and a little soggy. Very ordinary. 3.25/5

The white chocolate panna cotta, was light, not overly sweet and gelatanous. It was silky, smooth and light. Almost like tauhuay. 4.25/5.

Reviewed by Sumosumo
Photos by ieat

Conclusion

My thoughts mirror Sumosumo's so I think that we both have similar taste when it comes to Italian food. Do read our other kakis comments on their own experience.

Acknowledgements

Thanks to Damien for organizing the session.
Big thanks to Gerri and Mauro who hosted us and donated a grand total of $1115 to charity.

Footnote:
We are sensitive to the fact that serving out 36 dishes at the same time may mean that quality might not be as great as if the chef only had to prepare the one dish. So this should be kept in mind when reading the review.

11 Unity Street,
Robertson Walk #01-27/28
68369541
www.cugini.com.sg
15% off for ieatishootipost readers till the end of the month

The link to my previous post on Cugini is here.

18 comments:

iJeff said...

It was my first visit to Cugini. The restaurant is tastefully decorated with a nice and cosy ambience. sumo has more or less summed up my dining experience. My top 3 favourite dishes of the day were the Sicilian style seafood soup (4.5/5), Sardinia spaghetti (4.5/5) and roasted lamp chop (4.25/5). Will definitely bring my friends there to try their other pasta.

Thanks ieat and mien for organising this great tasting session. Also thanks Gerri and Mauro for hosting us and your generosity in donating all the proceeds to charity.

ice said...

Totally agree about the pastas at Cugini. The Sardinia spaghetti was perfectly al dente with a very good bite to it when I tried.

Looks like a great makan session. I've tried the ossobuco & seabass ravioli on my previous visits & I thought they were excellent. I'm big on ravioli, seems like I've to cover the lamb ravioli next.

P. Chong said...

interesting tasting, I must say.

For me, a quick review is as follows:

1. starter. Agree with sumosumo...forgetable. The red prawns were beautiful, but overcooked and tough.

2. Spaghetti. I would have liked it a little firmer, and a bit more garlic. But the way the sauce is served was perfect. Many Singapore prepared pasta dishes are more soupy than the ones you find in Italy. A good test if there is too much pasta is if after eating, the plate should be clean, with no gravy. Cugini's was.

3. Ravioli. Superb. Fresh pasta, stuffed with really, really tender lamb.

4. Beef cheeks. Too mushy. I suspect the beef is overcooked (suspect too long on a low heat, rather the reverse). It was tender, succulent. But provided nothing for the palate to work with. Taste wise, it was very bland. Almost like baby food.

5. veal. I didn't like the crust, but that's probably me. I disliked herb crusts. The veal within was nothing special.

6. lamb chops. Best amongst the mains for me. But would have been better if the outsides were crisped with a blowtorch or hot skillet after roasting. Doneness was perfect medium rare. A bit too fat, but that is the nature of lamb. Have definitely tasted better, but this is not a bad dish.

7. desserts were ok. Pana cotta was like a firm condensed milk...very sweet, very creamy. Tiramisu was equally pedestrian. Both could do with more punch and focus on the flavours.

8. the aperitives were also lack lustre. Maybe its the budget, but some Asti Spumante (inexpensive Italian sparkling wine) would have been more interesting.

9. and finally...no espresso!! Italian place, and no espresso! I didn't ask for one, and didn't see an espresso machine or barista in attendance. But espresso was not offered as part of the degustation menu.

A longer thought piece will be posted in my blog, with pictures later.

P. Chong said...

oh...many thanks to Gerri for hosting, Mien for organizing, and Les for introducing.

It was an enjoyable lunch.

Rachelle said...

Whoa! Cooking for 36 people at the same time is no simple task...I'm amazed that Mauro, Gerri and staff were able to pull it off! Hats off to them...Yes, Les is right, I'm sure the real food quality and taste will be presented at their best during normal serving time. Although I'm just a reader and was not there, I applaud their generosity and effort for hosting this session.

Damien said...

A big thanks to Gerri & Mauro for hosting us and feeding us to the brim with their dishes and makan kakis for attending :)

It was a real pleasure catching up with Fashion Foodie & Drazarael again after a long absence :)

I enjoyed the sardinia pasta, which was excellente with its firm bite and flavourfully well-balanced. A simple dish wonderfully executed.

The ravioli was exactly how it should be - nicely textured fresh egg pasta with a complementary moist lamb filling.

There were a few kakis that commented the soup was a tad too salty but this dish worked for me. It's reminiscence of the soupe de poisson I had in France with its rich and slightly briny stock infused by the long hours of simmering the fruits of the sea.

Just the effort that goes into making this bowl of soup should be lauded :)

Of the three meats served, the lamb was my favourite - served pink, moist and juicy.

I do agree with Sumo that the sauce could be a tinge sweeter to complement the gameiness of the lamb, but that's just a personal preference.

The braised beef came a close second with its melt-in-your-mouth and slightly buttery texture.

Tastewise, it was slightly underseason but no big issues on that as it could be rectified by salting it.

The white chocolate panna cotta was not overtly sweet, cloying nor had any holes heheheh as I've seen in some finer establishments - one of the better ones I've had a long while.

Overall, a very enjoyable meal with great company to the boot.

Once again, a big thanks to Gerri & Mauro for generously donating all proceeds from this event to AG Home.

Great food for a good cause, what a great way to start the week!

sumosumo said...

looks like so far, the kakis found the pastas up to the mark, excellent and well executed, but a few hit and misses on the meat dishes and desserts.

guess Mauro and Gerri will have to tweak and finetune those dishes which need working on. I think generally the meats and teh accompanying sauces were a little bland for most palates, as artichoke in itself is relatively flavorless, and the cocoa too subtle.

the tiramisu leaves room for improvement, as there are many many good tiramisus out there in the market. i think everyone didnt have a chance to try the cheese tart with citrus honey. that is a winner.

ieat said...

Yes some of our kakis commented that the seafood soup is too salty. To me it is ooommph! You can't take too much of it but the small amount that I had was great. If you are really adverse to salt, ask them not to add the capers because that is where all the saltiness is coming from.

The experience is akin to when I ate at Wah Kee Prawn noodle soup, except this one is even more concentrated.

liverpool1965 said...

the ravioli's the one I'd try!

jems said...

For appetizers, prawn as too dry. The fact that the arugula is already bitter yet they chose to pair the prawn with a bitter sauce didn't go well for me.

soup was a tad too salty for me though it's prob meant to be like that. However it was good flavored and I actually like the aroma of it alot.

Now I know what you guys meant by fresh pasta that is al dente. Although it is made in house by them, it is still essentially processed and dried so it is still dried pasta. Please correct me if I am wrong?

All the prawns served in the various dishes were not exactly that fresh and succulent.

Liked the ravioli skin, just the right bite and thickness for ravioli. Filling of the lamb was a bit too mushy though.

For the mains, wagyu beef cheek was too disintegrated like how others put it and lacked flavour. Didn't like the accompanying sauce too. In fact the whole color and presentation shouted wrong.
Lamb chop. The stench was too strong and it came too raw. After the brought back to the kitchen to cook it, it came out tough on the sides. I am a lamb eater btw. Veal was average too and likewise a tad dry and also lacked flavour

Desserts. Tiramisu was average. I actually liked the creaminess and the milkyness of the white choco panna cotta - it worked for me :)

However kudos for making this a charity event~!

Holy Drummer said...

I totally love seafood soup, but even this has breached my threshold for saltiness. Can afford to go less heavier on the capers.

The spaghetti was the star for me. I've never had pasta with such a delightful texture. Truly Al Dente & flavourful throughout every strand. I thoroughly enjoyed this dish.

The Ravioli was well executed too, the flavours of the lamb was very intense & very rich.

The lamb chop was also done to my liking, medium, though maybe a rosemary demiglace or simply a dash of rock salt would have been the perfect complement.

Beef cheek was very melt-in-the-mouth, but could be better seasoned. one-ninety is still the benchmark for my favourite beef cheek ever.

Dessert was surprisingly good for me. I enjoyed the tiramisu and the panna cotta, the latter being very different from conventional ones. Found out it was white chocolate. Yum~

If I would choose, I would come back especially for their pastas.

Thanks to Les, Mien for organising. And the kind hospitality of Mauro & Gerri for whipping up a wonderful lunch for us. The company was fantastic!

ieat said...

I feel that I owe Cugini an apology.

There was some miscommunication in organizing the makan session. To them, they were just throwing a small party so that us makan kakis could get together. But to us and me initially, I thought of it as a tasting session and portrayed it as so.

To be fair, for a proper tasting session, 36 is just too many people for them to showcase the best of their skills. It would have been more accurate if I just invited 10 people. Then they would have been able to really make sure that each and every dish was up to the usual standards. But on the other hand, I wanted to include as many of the makan kakis as I can so that no one feels left out.

I just went down today to eat the sea urchin spaghetti and it was the best seafood spaghetti I have tried. Their performance last Sunday was certainly not their best.

Amagada said...

I really must applaud Mauro and Jerry for their generosity to have hosted all of us and donating the collection to charity! I thought the portions were generous and appreciated the extra effort in typing out the menu that was placed on every seat, plus the special cocktail to start with.

My favourite dish was the seafood soup. Only wished I had freshly baked soft bread to dip. I honestly didn't think it was salty until others said it was then suddenly I thought - yah, it is kinda salty.

It was a nice Sunday lunch with good food and good company!

Thanks to Mien and ieat for organising.

lovejade said...

Hi all,

Wanna thank Mauro and Gerri for the generosity and warm hospitaly while we were there. =)

Thanks for sharing with us the authentic italian cuisine.

Will be back for more!

Lovejade

iJeff said...

Went back to Cugini for lunch on 2 Apr with ieat, sumo, jems and chocolat.

Mauro prepared a Sardinian Seafood Spaghetti for ieat (not in the menu), which was excellent! You guys should give it a try. Just tell Gerri/Mauro that you want the "Leslie Seafood Spaghetti".

ieat said...

Actually iJeff, they are quite happy to make something special for anyone who asks for it. You know, its like going to a Japanese restaurant and asking for the Chef's selection of sushi.

They are always importing interesting stuff from Italy, so when you tell them just give me whatever you think is good, you get to try some interesting stuff!

sc boy said...

My colleague tried this. Food was great. Price was reasonable. BUT service was very slow. The entree took 45 minutes (brucheta) and there were nothing served before that (not even bread). The main course came 30 minutes later (after the entree). Apparently, this didn't just happen to my colleague but also to the next table who had waited even longer. I think they were so frustrated that they took 10 minutes to finish the dinner and paid and left.

Has anyone experienced the same?

ItalianRestaurants said...

Great review! This restaurant sounds like a great place to eat! Italian cuisine is delicious!

Post a Comment