Thursday, July 31, 2008

Cilantro Modern Asia: Wagyu Shabu Shabu $15!

This Stall in Closed

Wagyu Shabu Shabu or Sukiyaki $15 (Normal Beef Shabu Shabu $7)

There are some things that sound too good to be true. Now if you are an optimist, your response to such things is to quickly go and find out if it really is true but if you are a pessimist, then you would sit back and mull over the thought that there ain't no such thing as a free lunch.

So would you consider yourself an optimist or pessimist if I were to tell you that you can get a Wagyu Shabu Shabu for $15? It's no bull (pun intended), this Wagyu Shabu Shabu is going for $15, but there is one catch --- you have to eat it in a coffee shop. "Phew, that's not too bad", I think I hear you say.

Now, for the readers who are really really skeptical, I post the picture on the right for you. Hope you are convinced.

When Jacky of Cilantro (Remember $15 Foie Gras?) said she was going to do modern Japanese food at her Marine Terrace branch, I was excited. Excited because, I know that she would go all out to give the customers something of quality but at rock bottom prices.

Good Japanese food depends on good produce and sadly a lot of places that sell Japanese food in hawker centres are not giving us good quality stuff. Now, I am not talking about the top grade Otoro, but simply a place that sell Mid-Ranged Japanese food at Hawker ranged prices. That would be a great idea for a family outing wouldn't it? Thankfully after a bit of gentle prodding, Jacky caught on the idea and decided to procure some Wagyu for the launch of her stall in Marine Terrace. Now it is up to the response from the general public to decide if we are going to see more Wagyu in coffeeshops!

For $15, you get around 5 slices of beef plus a pot of either shabu shabu or sukiyaki stock. They also serve Ponsu and Goma sauce to go with it which is quite unexpected of a $15 shabu shabu! There really is not need to tell you that the Wagyu is really melt in your mouth beefy goodness is there? 4.5/5


Wagyu Don $9.80

So what else would you do if you invested in an expensive meat slicer and you have a few kg of Wagyu Sirloin in your fridge? Why, you do a Wagyu Don, that's what. Now believe me, you don't have to Argue with Wagyu. The meat is just plain tasty no matter what you do with it. It's great whether it's dipped in soup, fried in teriyaki sauce or even eaten raw. So I'd say this could be the best bowl of Gyu Don I have tasted if only they had used better rice and the teriyaki sauce was tweaked a little. Jackie assured me that they will be changing the supply of rice to match the quality of the Wagyu. Whatever it may be, you'd be hard pressed to get something with the name "Wagyu" on it for less than $10 anywhere in Singapore. 4/5


Charshu Ramen $6

The Ramen here is very commendable. The soup is tasty enough, but I thought it could be just a little smoother (ie more fats from the marrow dissolved in the soup). Amagada on the other hand said the soup was surprisingly nice. The Chashu here is really good and quite addictive. Incidentally, don't you think Chashu is a bit of a misnomer? Should be called Lor Bak instead right? 4/5


Family Feast $18

The Family Feast is designed for families with kids (like mine). How often have you gone to a Japanese Restaurant and every time you order the tempura, it comes only in a small portion for $12? What we need is a family feast type platter where you get a variety of fried favourites like Pork Tonkatsu, Breaded Prawns, Chicken Karage, Potato Croquettes, Nuggets and Chicken Wings. As mother would say, "Jia Kau Song Song" (Eat till you are satisfied). Nothing out of the ordinary, but it's a dish the kids would love and gives the adults an excuse to indulge. 4/5


Teriyaki Chicken $6

I have to include this picture because I managed to catch the drop of lemon juice falling onto the Teriyaki chicken. Ahhhh, satisfaction.

Anyway, teriyaki chicken is a staple for any Japanese eatery and although it is easy to do, (who hasn't cooked teriyaki chicken at home?), it is very hard to get that special smoky charred taste. It is highly dependent on the quality of the soy sauce used. The one here is competent but I felt still had that "Chinese" taste to it. Kids will love it, but I still haven't found.... what I'm looking for. 3.75/5


Pan Seared Tuna $9.80

For the more adventurous, Cilantro offers a few more upmarket dishes like this Pan Seared Tuna in miso sauce. It is the kind of thing that you don't readily find in most of the Japanese Chain Restaurants in Singapore. Definitely worth a try if you are tired of the standard Japanese fare. 4/5


Banana Chocolate Mousse Cake $4.90

For dessert, you have to try their Banana Chocolate Mousse Cake which will satisfy most chocoholics except for the most fastidious ones. 4.5/5. The tiramisu is also very good. 4/5

Conclusion

We need to demystify the Wagyu and bring this wonderful tasting meat to the heartlanders. I hope to see more Wagyu appearing in food courts and mid ranged Japanese restaurants which will increase the awareness and demand for this product which will in turn mean that it will become standard fare for more Japanese eateries out there. When the Ah Gong and Ah Mah start to coin their Hokkien word for Wagyu, then we know we have reached our goal. In the meantime, if you want to continue to see Wagyu in the coffeeshop, then you have to do your part to go down and support them so that they will continue to sell it!

Now apart from the Wagyu (which is great even as sashimi), the rest of the fare is competent but don't go there expecting the same standards as your favourite Japanese restaurant. The main selling point it that it is a place where you can bring the kids to eat pretty decent Japanese food and not burn a hole in your pocket.

Cilantro Modern Asia
Blk 59 Marine Terrace
(Coffeeshop)
Opens 10am to 10pm daily

Disclaimer: I had an active role in planning the menu

What to do next?

Read about the $15 Foie Gras
Read about other Japanese Food
Read about other stalls in Katong and Joo Chiat
Grab a traditional cup of Kopi at the rustic Chin Mee Chin after that!

58 comments:

Louis Tan said...

Japanese 'charshu' is like that one... I was wondering what was up with it too, when I was first exposed to it... =/

But sometimes it can be surprisingly tasty, even if not the red roasted meat you're used to!

Holybro said...

OMG!!!

I thought Cilantro was only in Bukit Merah, din noe that there was one so close my home

Thats it....

I am gonna try it out tomorrow...I will set Ya Kwang as my benchmark, to taste the Shabu Shabu and the Don (spread over a few weeks)

The family feast looks so good I think I can probably wallop it up all by myself :)

Ok... 1st thing on my to-do-list after school...Cilantro!

JENCOOKS said...

Me toooo, Cilantro nearby geez.. like HB, I thot it was in BMerah with the foie talks...I love the shabu shabu and wagyu at coffee shop? unbelievable;

It's bringing something high on the pedestal down? or let the light shine everywhere?

alex said...

oops, the egg in the ramen has not been cooked to restaurant standards.. yolk shouldnt be grey at the edges ;)

cactuskit said...

Its only 5 mins walk from my home. Too bad my lunch and dinner all lined up for next few days. Will try soon.

hAPPy889 said...

There's another stall at Old Airport FC right? Do they have these on the menu as well?

Is it difficult to get parking weekday evenings nearby?

yummytummy said...

I love your blog! other blogs usually feature expensive restaurants or pretentious chi chi places, but you make an effort to find cheap and good food. keep up the good work! About shabu shabu, I bought some from NTUC that day. big mistake. Very bad. haha.

wahcow said...

that looks like 5 pieces for 15 bucks....good deal !!...

think time to organise office outing.....

khim said...

hmmm... for me, e wagyu beef in e first picture dun look very appetizing to me.. (maybe it's defrosted look doesn't appeal to me)

i still prefer Jason's wagyu shabu shabu anytime! =)

ieat said...

Yes but this one is a one person serving for 15 while Jason is big pot for 48! But for you one serving not enough hoh!

holybro said...

Tried this afternoon the Wagyu Don and the Teriyaki chicken.

If truth be told, the rice was not good as it was hard, the salad that came with up was not up to expectation too.

But the beef was the saving grace for me as it tasted exactly what I wanted it to be. 4/5

I wanted to order just the Teriyaki Chicken, but the guy mistook it and thought I wanted the rice also, so it came out as Teriyaki Chicken Don, but nvm..just did not touch the rice...

Chicken was grilled pretty nicely, but I was hoping they would marinate the chicken more to give it more flavour. 4/5 also


Funny to say, the Chocalate Banana Mousse was the dish of the day for me. The Chocalate was thick, creamy and went extremly well with the banana...Awfully Chocalate got competition liaoz.. 4.5/5


Nuff' said...time to get Jason to do me a Wagyu Beef Hor Fun!

just a girl said...

Same. I ordered the teriyaki chicken don last night and the chicken was bland and not gorgeous and charred like the photo posted. Hope this is just teething issues as its a new stall. I'm going to order the same food suggested. Really hoping the stall will stay.

cactuskit said...

Wagyu beef hor fun!!!??? Wow!!! I wanna try that too.

I trust that once the teething problems settle down, the food quality would pick up at Cilantro. Just 3-4 days of operations so far.

wahcow said...

somehow...i read it as

wagyu beef for fun.....

liverpool1965 said...

ok time to check the desserts out! if holybro says Awfully Chocolate got competition, must try! :)

Golden Peony for fun sounds better ? cactuskit, wahcow ;)

cactuskit said...

3rd day I'm resisting attempts to make me tekan Wahcow on GP.

JENCOOKS said...

The latest Wahcow Fun - wahseeliao...

JENCOOKS said...

The latest Wahcow Fun - wahseeliao...

jems said...

ok I have to say this, beef to me is given. You buy good beef u get good meat. Anyone can do it at home. What sets a shabu shabu aside is the soup base and the whole dining experience in a nice restaurant enhance the quality of the food. Ya Kwang's soup base could do with alot of improvement for me but I do agree with the good portion thus making it a great value. With increasing choices and competition in dining offering, offering higher end food at FCs is definitely a tough call.

Anonymous said...

Dear all, hello :) Sorry for having this under this post..but need some help!! truly appreciate it... can anyone recommend me a 1) good 2)reasonably priced 3)central/ convenient location for Shanghai food?

The 牛蛙,水煮鱼,fried beans, xiao long bao etc? Heard about "Old Shanghai Xiao Long Guan", but it seems to be rather pricey from the reviews.

Any good recommendations? Thank you!

Jamieh

angela said...

Gee... sorry to say, but u sure u call dat shabu shabu? Iz more like Kaminabe. Actual shabu shabu has no soup base... I went w my kids but was utterly disappointed. One sure thing which puts me off is de fire. I could not even dip my third pc of wagyu beef and de fire was already out! de rest of de time, soup was lukewarm... made me feel pressurised to 'cook' my beef and finish them up quickly... To pay 30 bucks for 2 shabu shabu, I rather spend my dough at restaurants. I think iz an experience but I will not go back again. Iz too hot too...

jems said...

hi angela, kaminabe is paper hotpot. shabu shabu is soup based. I haven't heard or seen shabu shabu with no soup base. Perhaps you can enlighten me? Or did you mix shabu shabu with sukiyaki?

angela said...

Hi Jems,

sorry but i meant soup base as in de soup for shabu shabu shld be purely juz water while hotpot kami has either spicy or non spicy soup. Anyway, I dun quite enjoy it. I had de potato croquette or something... not dat fantastic too.. JMO ;)

Marissa said...

Purely just water? That means Ya Kwang also got it wrong? I like soup base shabu shabu...

ladyironchef said...

so its only cilantro marine terrace that has the japanese food and the other two branches dun have?

ieat said...

Yes Japanese food at Marine Terrace, Western at Bukit Merah.

Most Singaporeans are used to some soup base rather than plain water which is why they do it that way. You can also choose sukiyaki soup base too.

1 kg of Wagyu costs $150 if you buy it at the butchers. Most Steak restaurants sell it for $40 per 100g. So to get 5 slices or about 100g for $15 plus the soup and vegetables and the dips, I think we should all secretly smile already.

If you want plain water with your shabu shabu, just ask for it. I am sure they can accommodate such a simple request. But don't ask for discount hoh!

jems said...

err no la, it shouldn't be just water. It's still stock/dashi made of sea kelp/kombu. There are many different grades of kombu too of cuz. Making a good kombu dashi is the basic any japanese chef will have to 1st learn.

ieat said...

Actually when I ate at Ohsumi, it was just water with a piece of radish in it. Sure don't taste any dashi in it at all. I prefer sukiyaki or a dashi base

liverpool1965 said...

yup when I was at Beppu, stock was water plus a slice of radish.. :)

ieat said...

Well keep updating us on your report! One thing about them though is that Jackie keeps an eye on the comments here and is constantly trying to improve based on feedback. So your comments are directly impacting on the quality of the food. You can also suggest things that you want to eat and she might just introduce it!

21st century hawkerism at work!

angela said...

Do something to de fire. U cant possibly hurry me to salvage my wagyu beef within dat 3 mins flame...

I give credit to introducing wagyu beef to de heartlanders, I am not complaining abt them. But Pls do something to make de fire go on at least until I finish 3/4 of my food. BTW, I am quite a fast eater, so dun blame me for getting pissed over de idea to 'cook' my beef in lukewarm water. BTW, u may b able to lessen de water in de soup too... a little too much..

Oh yeah, ur receipt, pls have ur stall's name printed on it too.. JMO

jems said...

anyway, to make dashi, you add kombu to water and turn it off once it brings to bowl and then also need to cool it off blah blah (sorry can't remember the last steps very long never make liao). So you really either add alot or use some good grade kombu to get that very slightly natural sweetness flavour.

so far I haven't had it with plain water yet keke. Most places like ieat said substitute with a light stock that has some soyu and mirin in it.

just a girl said...

That would be a little tricky as I am commenting from Hong Kong right now, left on Sat night which is why we couldn't try anything more :D I'll be back but that would be 6 weeks later. Am sure the other readers will feedback though :D Btw, love the comments on the photos of the Canon workshop, you guys look like you had lots of fun :D

ieat said...

Oh yes, it was such a success that we are discussing about organizing another workshop for those who missed out the last time because it was oversubscribed.

cactuskit said...

I'm learning so much just listening to this great discourse on shabu shabu.. Hahahah.

J said...

it's just across my block!!! O_O! *excited*

will go try tml night. hehehehe

cactuskit said...

So we're neighbours, J : ). Tell us how your dinner went.

Damien said...

Azuma Shabu Shabu at Cuppage Plaza only provide a pot of water for cooking the wagyu beef and I had an amazing experience there.

For pork shabu, Ohsumi, as reviewed in this blog a couple of months ago is also worth trying.

Holy Drummer said...

Well according to Ya Kwang, the traditional shabu shabu does contain only water and nothing else.

But becus we Singaporeans are so used to the dashi stock soup base - customers will 'hantum' Jason if he serves only plain water.

cactuskit said...

Remind him we'll humtum him if he stops selling food in Singapore. ; )

The Dictator said...

haha... its not easy to admit one's mistake

J said...

the dinner was ok, cactuskit. but i think i might have to give it a few more try to really know if it's worth introducing to ppl. went dwn on tuesday but the shop was closed. i'm a bit surprised since i brought all my supporters (my folks) dwn with me to try. thought it's opened daily.

not-so-positive observations:
1) there were 2 menus and the sign board. items & pricing are not consistent on each platform.
2) barely halfway through my dinner.. my shabu shabu fire died. luckily i dunked all the meat in right frm the start.
3) menu (booklet) design looks nice at first but examine it a little more closely (sorry, bad habit) it's actually quite confusing.

positive experiences:
1)my mom finished up her tempura don. (she's usually very picky)
2)dad was happy to find out that my shabu shabu only cost him $7. had to stop him from ordering another one for me.

er..so far, if i have to be frank about it. not implying it's bad, but i'm not impressed yet.

suggestions to the menu:
since you added in the photos to the menu to let customers have an idea of how certain food items look, it's useful if the photos has numerics indicated on it to link back to the numbered items in your menu.

to provide instant link between image and text = more scannability. =)

J said...

wah lau. just realised my comment super long. paiseh.

jesuslovesme said...

Try this Japanese self-BBQ place which serves a variety of good quality beef, Aburiya, located at QuaySide (60 Robertson Quay #01-03).

Must try the Wagyu tasting platter (Wagyu Tokumori Set) which consists of a variety of Wagyu beef cuts for $29.90++. I personally feel that the serving is considerably generous for that price.

Don't miss out on the Wagyu beef tongue (Wagyu Jo Tan) @ $25.90++ and Spinach salad (Horenso salad) @ $10.80++, simply delicious.

However, this is not the economical kind of place but the prices are reasonable for the good quality beef they serve.

Encouraged to go in groups of 3-6 pax, can try more yummy items and very importantly share the cost. :P Reservation is definitely recommended especially on weekends. (Tel: 6735 4862)

Disclaimer: I am neither the boss nor the employee of Aburiya, just a satisfied customer over the years. cHeeRs! :)

jems said...

cactuskit, ya we need to know the opening hours. Seem like Cilantro has not been consistent in their opening hours at both east coast and bukit merah outlets...

so traditional shabu shabu is served only with water~~ never know that. never see that on Japan Hour too. Must ask my bro if it's like this all in Japan. Like that very easy to make shabu shabu at home~!

ieat said...

Hi Jesuslovesme, Jesus loves me too!

Anyway Aburiya has already been blogged.

http://ieatishootipost.sg/2007/02/aburiya-japanese-bbq.html

Yes it is good but I feel that though the price may seem competitive, the quantity you get is not much. Still a great place to enjoy Jap BBQ. However, I would like to see this concept in a Coffeeshop, with prices about 30% less than a restaurant.

cactuskit said...

Well, you can ask Jackie later at dinner. ; ). Commit her to a time. Hahhaha.

Camemberu said...

Ah, I tried them today. Tempura don and wagyu beef don. The toppings were reasonably good but you are right about the rice - it is a bit of a letdown (well, can't have everything at those prices, can we?).

cactuskit said...

I think they are gonna change the rice after the feedback. Quite challenging due to costing, they say.

Anonymous said...

Hi there,

I went down to Cilantro Modern Asia yesterday at about 1.30pm in an attempt to try out their dishes but unfortunately it was not open...

Is there anyone who can tell me why is it so? Are they close on every tue??

Thank you.

cactuskit said...

I understand that they close every Tuesday at the Marine Terrace branch and every Monday for the Bt Merah branch.

Dominic said...

I wished I tried something you posted here. I definitely wasted some calories on bad food at Cilantro.
went there for dinner today and had the Pork Sausage with Mushroom Sauce ($8) which Jacky recommended.
calling it modern asian for rojak cuisine is a bad excuse.
This was their version of sausage w mushroom sauce:
Two warm sausages in Japanese curry sauce. I’m guessing one was spicy and one was normal based on the different color of the sausages. The center of the sausage was still cold and the meat tasted powdery. This was served with Chinese long grain rice with teriyaki sauce with shredded cabbage covered in Japanese mayonnaise on the side. There was also miso soup to accompany the main course. Overall the food preparation didn't work for me and it was a terrible experience. 0/5

hugeyes said...

I am quite disappointed with the food. Personally, didn't think the food is value for money. When I visited the place yesterday at 6pm, most of the dishes are sold out. The Shabu Shabu came with beef that was not fresh and with a lot of fats.

The Wagyu beef ramen cost $9.80. Too little beef. I suggest that they can add some sweet corn to the ramen.

ieat said...

Hi Hugeyes, I don't dispute your review. It is your personal taste. But you mention Wagyu and complain that the beef has too much fats at the same time which does not make sense to me. If you order Wagyu, you would want more marbling right?

Anonymous said...

Went to the stall @ Marine Terrace on Sat and tried their Wagyu Sukiyaki and is rather disappointing as the soup is not SOLID enough...too plain, but the dipping sauce goes very well with the beef..yummy. We ordered Wagyu Don the portion of the beef looks little on the bowl but it is tasty. The owner recommended a beef skewers(3 pcs of beef on each skewer(x2)and it cost $13.80) rather costly but if you are a beef lover the beef just melts in your mouth. Tried another pan fried yam cake with XO chilli sauce another dish recommended by the boss, however we all felt that the yam cake is soft and tasty enough without the chilli. The salmon don is disappointing.

Anonymous said...

Btw both branch at Bukit Merah & Old Airport road seems no longer in business. Got their name card and both locations are has been strike off.

Anonymous said...

I went to the coffeeshop just now for late lunch. The stall is gone...

hAPPy889 said...

Yup, went there for dinner yesterday evening. The stall is gone, only the sign board is left. No sign as to where they went to.

Post a Comment